nancyp Site Admin
Joined: 26 Jan 2004 Posts: 774 Location: Vancouver, WA USA
|
Posted: Fri May 11, 2018 2:13 am Post subject: WikiTree for Dr. Donald Gradeless - James Elder (1712-1818) |
|
|
Dr. Donald Gradeless posts his ancestors on WIKITREE.COM as "JAMES ELDER (1712-1818), with daughter Agnes ELDER, found in Franklin Co PA.
Adds JAMES' father as ROBERT ELDER of PAXTANG ...
at
https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Elder-103
My comments:
“Because of the differences in Y-DNA discovered, I need to remove the names of ROBERT ELDER of PAXTANG, and all other ancestors above his name. “ He won’t do it! The WikiTree Admins added MY NAME to his entry for JAMES ELDER with the PAXTANG father!
and:
"In our ELDER DNA project we have discovered that
"Robert ELDER d. 1746 of PAXTANG PA"
has descendants analyzed as Haplogroup "I-M223 = Isles, Scots, Viking, and divisions,"
which does not match Y-DNA from our "FRANKLIN CO PA" group,
now analyzed in "R1b1 and divisions, such as R-M269."
"So the 2 ELDER families cannot be related by the direct male (paternal) ELDER lines.
See the separated DNA categories in the ELDER YDNA RESULTS chart.
at
https://www.familytreedna.com/public/Elder?iframe=yresults _________________ Nancy Elder Petersen
Vancouver, WA USA
Host, ELDER DNA project
results:
http://www.familytreedna.com/public/Elder
NancyElderPeterSEN@yahoo.com |
|