Joined: 26 Jan 2004
Location: Vancouver, WA USA
|Posted: Fri Oct 20, 2017 12:19 pm Post subject: "Wrong Robert" (1742-1818) of Paxtang who had no c
|DAR records (19) with "WRONG ROBERT" of PAXTANG (1742-1818) who had no children.
Search box. (scroll down for results)
Ancestor #: A037141
Service: PENNSYLVANIA Rank(s): COLONEL
Birth: 6-11-1742 PAXTANG TWP LANCASTER CO PENNSYLVANIA
Death: 9-29-1818 NEW ALEXANDRIA WESTMORELAND CO PENNSYLVANIA
PA ARCHIVES, 5TH SER., VOL. 7, PP 359, 362, 995-97
1) 4TH & 10TH BATTALIONS, LANCASTER CO. MILITIA
866 JOSEPH  JANE WALKER
4845 JOSEPH  JANE WALKER
7613 JOSEPH  JANE WALKER
40580 JOSEPH  JANE WALKER
45977 JOSEPH  JANE WALKER
96432 JOSEPH  JANE WALKER
178978 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
180113 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
177169 141 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
198654 MARTHA  ROBERT KERR
230500 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
233073 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
252309 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
253435 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
282591 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
350124 358 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
469555 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
494987 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
839382 JOSEPH  MARTHA JANE WALKER
= Supporting documentation available
= Descendants list available for this member and this ancestor
= Descendants list available for this member but not this ancesto
DAR (all Wrong - because Joseph is son of a different Robert ELDER (b. 1730 Perthshire, Scotland - d. 1807 Franklin Co PA) - Rev. War Ancestor for Nancy Elder Petersen, DAR Member #833222. Brother's Y-DNA #10042 matches "FRANKLIN CO PA" DNA group in ELDER DNA project.
"In our ELDER DNA project we have discovered that
"Robert ELDER d. 1746 of PAXTANG PA"
has descendants analyzed as Haplogroup "I-M223 = Isles, Scots, Viking, and divisions,"
which does not match Y-DNA from our "FRANKLIN CO PA" group,
now analyzed in "R1b1 and divisions, such as R-M269."
"So the 2 ELDER families cannot be related by the direct male (paternal) ELDER lines.
See the separated DNA categories in the ELDER YDNA RESULTS chart.
Adding COMMENT to "Wrong Robert" entries to show document:
"From A letter to Mrs. Grier"
(From 116 Spruce St, Philadelphia, July 16, 1919) - Gillispie Papers, FC EL - Historical Society of Pennsylvania, Phila. ....
"I have at hand a copy of the Bible record of the Reverend John Elder in which is given the date of birth of his son Robert as Friday June 11, 1742. This Robert lived in Swartara Twp, a later division of Lower Paxton, Dauphin Co. He was married by his father on Feb 7, 1769 to Mary J. Thompson. He served in both the Provincial and Revolutionary period with his father and was the Colonel in command of the Dauphin County troops in the War for Independence. He died Sept 19, 1818 and was buried beside his wife who had predeceased him some five years, in the church yard adjoining the Paxtang church of which he was long a ruling elder. He apparently had no children nor grand-children as his estate which was large was bequeathed to nieces and nephews. He always lived in this locality and in 1813 signed off a release to his brothers for his share of his fathers estate as settled in full. ....there is no record of any children and ample proof he died childless."
Sent also to WikiTree ELDER researcher
also to WikiTree Elder researcher
and to WikitTree Elder researcher
DNA Article by the DAR Registrar: SHARON WITHERS
Nancy Elder Petersen
Vancouver, WA USA
Host, ELDER DNA project